• Default layout
    • A
    • A
    • Font size:

    • +
    • -
Jump to main content

VDC

VET DEVELOPMENT CENTRE

  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Organisational Chart
    • Board & CEO
  • Professional Development
    • Professional Development
    • Conference
    • Webinar Recordings
  • Room Hire
  • News
    • VDC News
    • News Archive
  • Funded Opportunities
  • Layout:

    Default layout

    High contrast

  • Font size:

  • Legibility:

    Reset

    Low Brightness

    • Best Legibility
      • Aa
      • Aa
      • Aa
  • Layout width:

    • Liquid
    • Full

News Archive


Font size: + -

Beware educational cargo cults!

Wed 12 February | News Archive,VDC News

In late 2018, John Hattie and Arran Hamilton published a ‘White paper’ entitled “Education cargo cults must die”.

An intriguing title; but what’s its message?

What are the cargo cults?

Hattie and Hamilton suggest that:

“Cargo cults develop when organizations or individuals spend their meager resources on the wrong things, declare success and congratulate themselves on a job well done—despite strong evidence to the contrary.”

In the white paper, they argue that a lot of education’s costs are fixed, like infrastructure building and maintenance, admin costs and – the biggie – staff salaries and benefits. Only 4%, they maintain, is spent on the “the procurement of education products/resources for use in the classroom and for in-service teacher professional learning.” So, they believe: “A well-spent 4% could be the proverbial “silver bullet” for education.”

What we do is most likely also influenced by a whole mess of biases, they suggest. These biases and influencers on practice which, among many they highlight, include (1) authority bias – where greater weight and accuracy is given to the opinions of an authority figure, and (2) confirmation bias, where we “collect and interpret information in a way that conforms with, rather than opposes, our existing beliefs.”

Another bias they identify is anecdotal fallacy – so, as they say, “Beware of testimonial porn.”

‘Not invented here’ is another biggie, as is the ‘bandwagon effect’, where we believe “something works because a large number of other people believe it works” and ‘conservatism’ is where we are not able to revise our beliefs sufficiently, even when we are presented with strong contradictory information.

Finally, there is what they call the ‘Ikea effect’ – where there is greater buy-in because the end user has been involved in building the product. However, this may limit the extent to which solutions are effectively localized and adapted.

In addition to these cargo-cult notions, a newspaper article by Tony Featherstone in the Sydney Morning Herald last year highlighted the use of short online modular training by organisations to ‘sheep dip’ their employees. This process, he maintains, is focused on providing cheap and cheerful compliance and ‘fast food’ focused training rather than providing really effective continuing professional development that helps their employees learn and improve practice.

Food for thought!

UPCOMING VDC PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT

e51e2234e1
  • 17 Mar

    professional learning events

    VET Chat: Industry Engagement - The Essentials

    Wed, 17 Mar 10:00AM–10:30AM
    $15 (inc GST)
    Participants will leave this VET Chat with a better understanding of how to keep records and maintain compliance, how much industry engagement is enough, as well as a wealth of ideas for industry engagement activities.
    Find out more...
    Register
  • 16 Mar

    assessment essentials

    Virtual Workshop: Quality Assuring Competency-Based Assessment Tools

    Tue, 16 Mar 12:00PM–1:30PM
    $80 (inc GST)
    Led by VET assessment and audit expert, Andrea Bateman, this 1.5-hour virtual workshop will give participants an understanding of the processes for reviewing assessment tools prior to use and how to evaluate assessment tools against the context of assessment requirements.
    Find out more...
    Register
  • 17 Mar

    teaching & learning strategies

    Webinar: 21st Century Skills - Currency for Success

    Wed, 17 Mar 12:30PM–1:30PM
    $55 (inc GST)
    Join Karen Dymke for this interactive webinar to learn strategies to build learner confidence and how to help students master the competencies needed in the workplace.
    Find out more...
    Register

VIEW LATEST NEWS

Archive

  • 2021
    • February (10)
  • 2020
    • November (11)
    • October (12)
    • September (10)
    • August (11)
    • July (14)
    • June (10)
    • May (11)
    • April (10)
    • March (12)
    • February (11)
    • January (6)
  • 2019
    • November (12)
    • October (9)
    • September (10)
    • August (9)
    • July (11)
    • June (5)
    • May (14)
    • April (4)
    • March (10)
    • February (8)
    • January (4)
  • 2018
    • December (4)
    • November (8)
    • October (9)
    • September (8)
    • August (12)
    • July (6)
    • June (11)
    • May (11)
    • April (10)
    • March (4)
    • February (10)
    • January (5)
  • 2017
    • November (10)
    • October (9)
    • September (5)
    • August (12)
    • July (4)
    • June (9)
    • May (9)
    • April (5)
    • March (11)
    • February (10)
  • 2016
    • December (5)
    • November (8)
    • October (8)
    • September (10)
    • August (14)
    • July (5)
    • June (1)
  • 2015
    • December (1)
  • 2014
    • December (1)
  • 2013
    • December (1)
  • FAQs
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Site Map

VDC

Level 8 379 Collins St, Melbourne
T: 1300 917 150
E: [email protected]

 

© VET Development Centre 2020