A recent briefing note published by the United Kingdom’s House of Lords Library asks whether AI is weakening the value of a university degree?
While the focus is UK higher education and its findings cannot be applied directly to the Australian VET sector, it nonetheless raises questions that VET educators and leaders are asking: if AI can produce work that once demonstrated a learner’s knowledge, how do we know what they can do, and what should education help them learn?
The briefing notes that AI use among UK university students is now widespread, including for assessed work. This has prompted concerns about assessment integrity and whether relying on AI can reduce the thinking and effort needed to learn. Some universities are responding with a mix of assessments that allow AI and those that restrict it, as well as considering oral or handwritten assessment. For VET, the practical question is how to assess the occupational knowledge and skills learners can apply, including when AI tools are part of their work (and when training package qualifications may not have been updated to reflect the use of AI across occupations).
The evidence in the briefing on the impact of AI on graduate jobs is quite nuanced. It notes that there have been declines in some entry-level roles in the UK but the same has happened in less AI-exposed sectors and therefore the shift in graduate employment may reflect wider economic conditions. Other analysis suggest that jobs are being reshaped, with employers seeking skills such as leadership and strategic thinking in roles previously considered entry level (as the latest JSA report notes).
The UK House of Lords briefing also finds little sign that demand for degrees has collapsed since the arrival of ChatGPT, and notes the arguments being made that subject knowledge can help people question AI outputs, while ethical judgement and social intelligence remain important.
Two of perhaps the biggest challenges for educators in VET and higher education to be contemplating are:
- AI eroding learning through ‘cognitive offloading” ie students are less engaged in their learning and hence have poorer understanding of what they should be learning and even memory loss about what they have been taught, and
- The replacement of some teaching work by ‘AI tutors’ such as the example of the London School of Innovation (LSI) which this year started offering masters degrees “where the bulk of module delivery is provided by AI tutors.” (The director of education at LSI apparently argues that this “allows for a more flexible and engaging personal experience than traditional lectures while also freeing up staff’s time for more one-on-one sessions with students.”)






